Excavators versus Backhoes

Whether you are a construction professional or work in landscaping, farming, or any other job where moving earth, debris, or other heavy objects is a regular task, then two of the most invaluable pieces of machinery in your arsenal are excavators and backhoes.

Both machines possess their benefits and are produced by top names in the industry – John Deere, Komatsu, Caterpillar, Hitachi, Hyundai, Bobcat, Kubota, Mitsubishi, Volvo, and many others. Powerful, built to last and known for their operational capabilities in challenging environmental and working conditions, they can be a worthy investment for your business. Read on for a brief overview of what each piece of equipment can offer, depending on your job requirements.

Why Excavators Rule
Komatsu excavator dumping earth into a heavy duty vehicle

If your work needs revolve around smaller jobs (home construction and remodeling, small businesses, landscaping, agriculture), then any number of mini excavators can get the work done. Small and lightweight, these highly versatile machines offer some benefits compared to not only their bulkier cousins but also to backhoes:

  • They are compact and lightweight. A model such as the John Deere 35G is ideal for minimizing ground damage due to its size and rubber tracks.
  • Most compact excavators are small enough for residential applications, easily fitting between a standard double gate or single fence panel when removed. They are great for areas where space is at a premium, such as occupied parking lots or even indoors for showroom construction.
  • A zero tail swing excavator features housing that does not overhang its tracks, making 360-degree operation a snap.
  • Unlike backhoes, compact excavators can use optional long and extendable arms, thereby making them more useful on a site where reach is critical.
  • Because of their relatively small footprint, a mini excavator like the Bobcat E32i can be transported to and from a job site more easily, often by a trailer-equipped full-size pickup or SUV.
  • A compact or mini excavator such as the Hitachi ZX10U-2 is more versatile than a backhoe, as it can be equipped with many optional attachments for different jobs, like an auger, breaker, grapple, quick coupler, roller, blade, and others.
  • The cabin on an excavator can rotate, giving the operator a better view of the worksite. The backhoe cabin is stationary, but its seat rotates so the driver faces whatever direction the backhoe faces.
  • A compact excavator can be equipped with rubber tracks, meaning less damage to soft ground worksites. In comparison, most backhoes feature large tires that will leave a visible trail in its path.
  • Most excavators, even “compact” models, can be utilized for jobs with much heavier lifting requirements.
  • Because of the number of optional attachments available, a mini excavator can be used for many different types of work. A backhoe is mostly limited to digging trenches, digging holes, or moving heavy tools or objects from one location to another.
excavator tears down a house

No matter your need, a compact, mid-, or full-size excavator can get the job done. Before choosing, just be sure to know the type of work being performed, the kinds of optional attachments that will be required, and any job site restrictions that would dictate what size machine to go with.

John Deere 35G mini excavator moving earth
Share

Related Articles

Under 4 Minute Maintenance: Greasing Excavator Fittings

Under 4 Minute Maintenance: Greasing Excavator Fittings

This can be used on any make/ model of heavy equipment, including excavators and skid steers. Greasing fittings helps all working parts run smoothly.
Easy DIY Excavator Maintenance: Full Final Drive Drain & Refill

Easy DIY Excavator Maintenance: Full Final Drive Drain & Refill

Here are the steps to drain and refill the final drive oil. Changing the oil drive is good maintenance so you can check for contaminants.
Less Than One Minute Maintenance: Change Out an Excavator Cab Filter

Less Than One Minute Maintenance: Change Out an Excavator Cab Filter

Cab filters help to filter the air going to the heater and air conditioning inside the cab. Learn how to change the filter on your excavator.
How To Refill Excavator Engine Oil: 250-Hour Service PART 3

How To Refill Excavator Engine Oil: 250-Hour Service PART 3

Refilling the engine oil helps the engine run smoothly - which is why it's done at a 250 hour service - but you don't need a mechanic to do it.
How To Change Excavator Engine Oil Filters: 250-Hour Service PART 2

How To Change Excavator Engine Oil Filters: 250-Hour Service PART 2

During a 250 service the mechanic will often change the engine oil filter while they are changing the oil. Learn how you can do it too.
Draining Excavator Engine Oil: 250-hour Service PART 1

Draining Excavator Engine Oil: 250-hour Service PART 1

Changing the engine oil in your excavator ensures that it will operate at the optimal level. The following steps will cover changing the oil in a CAT 314E excavator.
Heavy Equipment FAQs: Service Mechanic Answers

Heavy Equipment FAQs: Service Mechanic Answers

A heavy duty mechanic answers some common questions asked when servicing excavators, bulldozers, skid steers and other heavy equipment machines.
Changing Hydraulic Filters on an Excavator

Changing Hydraulic Filters on an Excavator

The hydraulic system has filters to prevent contaminants from entering the system. Learn how to change the filters using these steps.
2 Second Bolt Tension Inspection Using Only a Hammer

2 Second Bolt Tension Inspection Using Only a Hammer

Occasionally, you need to check the tension of the bolts as part of your preventative maintenance routine. Here is a quick way to check it with just s hammer.
How to Quickly Change the Air Filter on a Ditch Witch SK755 With Ease

How to Quickly Change the Air Filter on a Ditch Witch SK755 With Ease

Learn how to change the air filter on a Ditch Witch SK755 to keep your heavy equipment running in optimal condition.
Expert Advice for Heavy Duty Apprentices: Best Tools to Get You Started

Expert Advice for Heavy Duty Apprentices: Best Tools to Get You Started

As a heavy duty apprentice you're expected to have your own toolkit - but where do you start? We've got some quick tips on tools for HD apprenticeships.
Your Guide to Water Separator Fuel Filters on a John Deere 35G Excavator

Your Guide to Water Separator Fuel Filters on a John Deere 35G Excavator

A water separator fuel filter is that red ring inside the part filled with a mixture of water and fuel. Learn more about what it is and what it's used for.

Hello.

Let's get you signed up for deals and news. We won't send too many. Sign up and get 5% off your first order.